Jun 27, - Wahoo Elemnt GPS Cycling Computer, Garmin Edge CPS Bike GPS Buying Guide: How to choose the best Cycling GPS Computer?
I was kinda hoping for a more vibrant display.
And the speed of the basic user interface bits how fast it reacts is far slower than competitors. Way slower. That then allows you to route to saved locations or a bikke on the map. Saved locations appear in the list just by the street name.
You can only save your current location on the map. You can see an example bike computer with cadence for spin bike of it not exactly knowing what the roads are a lot of the time. Wahoo says this is planned by the end of June a timeline I think is reasonable. And funny enough, the developer of that app now elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin for Wahoo. Only 3rd party providers include elevation data ironically enough, Strava includes elevation data.
Finally, the ROAM will elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin pull in any starred Strava segments that you have in your account. Points of interest are shown on the maps automatically, as are more details about streets. I will note however that one super solid point of Wahoo is that they include the maps for all regions. By default the maps will come loaded for your region, and then you can tap to download maps for other regions if you travel.
This matches Sigma and Hammerhead, whereas Garmin requires you pay for additional maps — or download them for free from 3rd party sites which is cumbersome and annoying at best. So props to Wahoo for continuing to make it easy. A watch could fall apart and give gpz dire electrical shocks while doing so, but if it shows you on the wrong side of the road? Oh elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin no, bring on the fury of the internet!
GPS accuracy can be looked at in a number of different ways, but I prefer to look at it using a number of elenmt in real-world scenarios across a elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin number of activities.
I use other devices at once, trying to get a clear picture of how a given set of devices handles conditions on a certain day. For example, for watches I try to not place two units next to each other on my wrists, as that can impact signal. For cycling units, I arrange them on elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin handlebars using standard mounts — usually one on either side of the stem, often a bit separated from each other.
Next, as noted, I use just my daily training routes. The workouts you see here are just my hardware gloves for mountain biking daily workouts.
This has included workouts in: Amsterdam city, countryside and Mallorca mountains, ocean, countrysideCalifornia off-road, hills, forests, seaside. I rode this nearly a month ago, so while this firmware was bjke older, it still shows pretty solid GPS performance.
Heck, even a bridge overpass:. Everything here from the ROAM is spot-on. Now altitude was a bit of a garnin one. It seems everyone made mistakes here.
The one thing ROAM got most correct was me getting close to the sea. My turnaround point was basically a fishing village, elevated perhaps meters above garmim level. But we see drift from both. See, that low-point there I stopped and ate lunch. Of course, at elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin same time, we also see the Garmin units having trouble too.
Vivitar - 360 degree action camera - black MARQ is drifting again, beta as wellwhile the two Edge units were simply off-set from the start bad elevation fix where I started apparently. So in some ways the chart elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin more of a curiosity than anything. As you can see, the ROAM is perfectly spot-on the road the entire time, even if I zoom way the heck in:. In other words, it should correctly pass in through the tunnel without any GPS wonkiness, and then come out clean the other side.
Of course, I made life difficult here on all the units because I actually stopped just after I went through the tunnel coming backstill below a cliff edge. And no issues at the end of the turnaround either.
Funny tidbit: You can see where I left the units on my bike and then walked closer to the edge with the MARQ still on my wrist. So what about elevation on this ride? Ask and you shall receive. You can see how it got a bad fix to begin with, and it just stayed bad. The remainder of the units nailed it though. So in those cases we saw slightly degraded GPS performance in those scenarios totally logical.
Here we were next to a highway, but actually we were also under some pretty significant trees on the trail and elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin substantial hill next to that. Super clean track through here. Same is true in town, even getting the correct side of the road properly:. And lastly, a ride last Friday through the tulip fields. Production all around! The elevation might appear crazy at first, but then carefully look at elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin scale.
Welcome to the Netherlands. Though I lack the geography to continue to test altitude related goodness going forward. So I kinda have to do that when I travel.
All of the charts in these accuracy portions were created using the DCR Analyzer tool. You can use it as well for your own gadget comparisons, more details here. Of course, there are plenty more how do i turn off portrait orientation lock in the product comparison calculator, so you can elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin your own charts here as well.
And again, remember you can mix and match and make your own product comparison charts over in the product comparison calculator. And within those parameters, elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin technically unlocks both achievements. And in fact, that app in the last few weeks got a solid user interface refresh. The challenge is, I think too much attention was paid to that app — and not enough to the unit itself.
When Wahoo entered the market years ago, and in particular with the BOLT 2 years ago, it provided a breath of fresh air. Something different, cleaner, and more cohesive. But now — it just feels out of date. At least not in the last few years. But the reality is, their competitors of today are fast and clean and now the ROAM is slow. And for Wahoo to essentially roll out what amounts to a handful of routing options for a new unit begs the question: What have they been doing for two years?
Of course, the reality is that true mapping navigation is hard. Really, really, really hard. It sounds easy in theory, but is super blke in practice. So I get that — totally. Something that would have distracted from the fact that the navigation on the ROAM is mostly half-baked still. Hopefully you found this review useful. Points can elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin used on your very next purchase at Clever Training bikf anything site-wide.
You can read more about the details here. By joining, you not only support the site and computrr the work I do here stiftung warentest fails 3 toddler bike helmets but you also get to enjoy the significant partnership benefits that are just for DC Rainmaker readers.
Or, anything else you pickup on Amazon helps support garmmin site as well socks, laundry detergent, cowbells. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked. If you would like a profile picture, simply register at Gravatarwhich works here on DCR and across the web.
Subscribe me to the newsletter. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You pacific explorer bike trailer review click here to Subscribe without commenting. Put me down in the camp desperate to leave garmih garmin eco system.
Elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin sigh. Garmin review comments: Should I buy an Edge or ? In the same camp. As an owner of many Garmin Edge bike computers, after my horrible experience with the Edgeif not for the Varia radar, I would have jumped ship to Wahoo.
I guess I elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin remain in the Garmin ecosystem for the foreseeable future. For me looking at a new head unit, the choice seems clear with the edge I travel a lot, so like the fact that Wahoo provides free regional maps. Yeah, the is 16 Gb, coputer about No microSD slot.
The was ok and certainly less unstable than my Forerunner XT which required giro mens rumble vr cycling shoes review resetting monthly… I only had to do a manual semi-reset procedure 2 or 3 times on the before the charging connector broke a common problem based on the forums — sadly this was at 13 months old and Garmin made it clear that this is all they expect their devices to last and thus I could not claim under EU consumer law gaarmin a replacement from the retailer.
My tri-watch is a 4 year old Suunto and despite the Movescount debacle I still have some confidence that Suunto will actually support it for a few more years, i. I realise this is anecdata although apart from my XT, all my Garmin devices — FR60, EdgeFR have died either inside or just outside a year of ownership — and that its not something you can include in a review not unless you release the review 3 years after the device is released!
Totally agree — I love that Wahoo elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin updating firmware longer term. Whereas Wahoo spreads that out over a much longer trail. The perception is that Wahoo keeps adding to products. Of computet, eventually Wahoo will get to the day where the products are too old and that will stop.
But for now, the perception that you outlined around Garmin sorta forgetting elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin customers is mostly true. Except that most of the updates that you get from Garmin are not so much new features but bug fixes. And for Wahoo to dlemnt what elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin effectively a x. Garmin has been rolling out generous feature updates whenever a new smaller unit would introduce features that a still-current bigger unit lacked.
Will the BOLT get all the new navigation features except for the colors? I thought it was a gimmick until I tried it and now I try elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin never ride on a road without it.
I know a lot of other people who are the same. Brad, glad you like your radar and sorry to hear you are having issues with the Edge battery. Reach out to us, mention Shawn Garmin suggested you get in touch about your concerns, and we will get this sorted. Add me to the list of Varia requesters. That and the unit seems to be buggy with its connection to the iPhone over these last several updates. I remember when they used to listen to and execute feature requests.
Garmin radar is no joke. Unfortunately, in typical Garmin fashion, elenmt drop the ball on the user experience.
Meaning as a car approaches, it switches from steady to flash. This gives the driver a potential startle just as they pass you. So f-ing dumb. For some reason, they elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin a hardware level setting around this.
This would pull me over line again currently using Wahoo. Balancing my loyalty across Garmin, Apple, and Wahoo can be difficult at times. Garmin does not lock Varia Radar users into their ecosystem too rigidly though, since they do provide a dedicated radar display unit part number I also have fallen into the camp of must have my radar. I just bought 2 additional varias as elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin for my 2 riding partners.
In my mind, it is the biggest safety innovation over the past decade. I find the radar useful on city streets. It goes off constantly, be but you can see where the gaps in traffic are without having to turn your head. It means he used the Amazon link that supports the site here.
The easy way is just to use any Amazon link from this site, either direct or indirectly. Works as well for just general things like toilet paper.
I was really hoping for something that gave me reasons to upgrade my garmin How does it feel, does it feel like you have a premium device Garmin in your hand or does it still feels like something plastic? Garmin always felt well build and sturdy, my Wahoo feels cheap. After 1. Looks like same built quality as the bolt. I had to replace sv bolt 3 times now because elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin page button is getting loose.
Not quite as plastic-feeling as the BOLT. Does the Roam display elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin when buttons are being pushed? However, it is not obvious to me reading your review. You also do not have your typical product comparison which gives the price. I think it would help if you put the price clearly right up front. After years of Wahoo and die hard fans trying to convince elwmnt and them that monochromatic screen was the thing and sigma 1200 wl wireless bike computer was rubish, and not that a big deal on navigation, Wahoo changes to color!
Does it have a simple battery percentage while charging? Simple things, simples things…. This new screen uses the same technology and adds 8 color support, while gwrmin even better visibility in sunlight. We took special care to only use color when we thought it added something for the user. I guess there are personal differences, but for me especially the route on Garmin Edge is nearly impossible to read elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin direct sunlight.
Of course it would help, if compurer could change the colors yourself. Beautifully clear, crisp screens; stellar battery life; good mounts; proper phone integration; idiot proof navigation that has never failed etc. I really like the bolt, works every time with no hassles. The colour screen seems sort of pointless, no? Great review ray.
Hopefully next year. This tarmin such a disappointing product. I have never missed having a colour screen. No idea why Gpw thought adding colour was useful?? davis california gps bike decoy sticker
What does it matter? I actually prefer old micro USB cables, because wherever you are in the world, you will find someone with such a cable to charge something.
But the most important thing, is that the USB C specification allows more current to flow which allows for faster charging of peripherals. People with older USB chargers and ports can use a cable with USB C at the device end elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin the device ships with a cable so why not move forwards when the new version is better in every way imaginable?
OK, that makes sense. Interesting that you called Wahoo out on the micro-usb port being so dated, yet nothing on Garmin doing the same? Your site depends on complete neutrality. Umm, I called out both of them above in the text? I hope Wahoo responds with a corresponding low-power mode, otherwise I may jump ship this summer.
The optional external battery would elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin real nice for randonneuring though, although I find that keeping your GPS connected to a USB battery pack while riding works well enough provided you have some sort of handlebar bag to keep the battery in.
My observation is that people riding with a Wahoo have less navigation oopses because gopro hero 3 battery compatibility this. The battery saver mode is actually interesting — and not terribly well understood. The main appeal for most is really the automatic shift from regular mode to battery saver mode when the battery gets super low during a ride, to get you to the end of it. The comparison table needs to be updated — you list the Elemnt Bolt twice, but the price elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin seems to be the Elemnt Roam.
Otherwise, great review. Same in the picture of all the devices. You enumerate the bolt where the roam should be I think. Thanks Ray for the review!! Elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin love the child protective services stockton california but often found them too dull on a sunny day with darker sunglasses on…. Like today in Amsterdam…. I am worried about switching from wahoo to Garmin echo system of supported devices.
But the long list of features and competitive price vs the new bolt make me willing to jump. Custom base maps — Garmin is the only device I know that does this. Looks like an afterthought here. I somehow get the impression that Wahoo could be working with them, and Garmin with Trailforks?
I really wish Garmin would take some notes on how nice Wahoo does their mobile phone integrations. They actually did just implement integration with MTB Project for your wishlist trails and routes, which sync just like a route from any other source. Not sure if they ever plan to implement that trail data on their basemaps. Elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin the notifications, is it just s SMS or will actually used protocol notifications arrive how much does a 450 dirt bike weigh WhatsApp or fb messenger etc?
There is a significant difference in bezel size between the actual unit and the picture rendering on the box and in the Wahoo announcement email… Needless to say, the actual display size on the rendering is bigger!
Any remarks on this? I am a loving owner of a Bolt, so no Wahoo hater here, but still, the real life Roam does not look so nice at elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin as the one on the rendering…. What a garbage strategy.
Thanks for pointing this out. Marketing is compute, but this is straight up dishonesty. Agreed that we should all want a useful and exact elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin of the product on the garin of the elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin box. Not sure that it happens in the majority of cases though.
The size of the bezels or the fact they have lied about it. Bigger, fluffier and stuffed with all the goods …. And the aluminum case is jewel-like and can be highly customized. The Mega C lives up to its name elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin a large 56mm diagonal garimn, and a long feature list that includes great battery life up to 32 hours and enough memory to store hours of rides.
It was also a complete nightmare to use. The new CA looks like it quashes the nightmares, keeps the powerful stuff, and adds a few enhancements. New features include a 56mm diagonal color screen, OpenStreet basemaps for navigation with turn-by-turn directions, compatibility with Bluetooth sensors, smartphone alerts, and Strava Live Segments. The can display up to 15 metrics on a single screen. The Garmin Edge is the gold standard for cycling computers with navigation options available on the market right now.
The how to make apps go straight to sd card color screen makes following an unfamiliar route easier. And, of course, it does what every good cycling computer does: Type keyword s to search. By The Bicycling Editors.
Intuitive Setup Wahoo Elemnt Easy customization via smartphone app. Tiny and Powerful Garmin Edge All the features you need without added complexity. Where Wahoo only has its name to a limited range of new products, Garmin has over a elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin of various product lines spanning multiple price points.
There are none more successful than the Garmin Edgea computer that Matt de Neef and hundreds of thousands of other cyclists… still uses today. The bottom of the elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin is cracked and it takes forever to boot up and find satellites, but I can still find no reason to spend several hundred dollars getting a replacement.
It does everything I need a GPS to do. Time — how much longer does my leave pass have? Distance — assuming I had an idea of how far I was going in the first place. Andy explains that eventually the Edge got old: As the founder of Everesting, Andy explains that for elevation attempts, the two wishes barmin any unit are battery life elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin elevation reliability. See below and there is actually so much elevation variation between units — even on the garmon computer brand and model — that the Everesting rules have changed.
The unit records the proof of laps, but the elevation gain is calculated of the known good full face mountain bike helmets under 80 elevation times by the hill repetitions. However, issues with the Bluetooth and more recently, data loss have Mitch itching for a new unit. The Garmin Edge middle is likely to be a popular upgrade for those loyal to the Edge left ; the new Edge right is there for those that want more advanced mapping functionality in a compact device.
Where so much loyalty sits with the old EdgeJames offers a beam of hope. We wondered how this could be since we figured there are likely only one or two navigation chipsets out there and expect they would act the same way when responding to the same GPS satellite.
Software differences? Black box stuff? The BOLT does lack the ability to route you back on course the way the does.
You get all elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin of beeps gike you go off course with the BOLT so you have little excuse to turn things around and get going in the right direction. I expect a software upgrade at some point would also bring BOLT on par with the elemht this capability.
Certainly hope so. To end this section at the start, there is one huge difference between the two head units when it comes to loading a route. With theyou need to download elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin route file to your computer, plug the into your computer, and then upload the route file to a right folder in the Garmin folder how to mount action camera on bike. Choose the folder called New Files rather than any of more elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin 20 others including those called Courses, Custom Maps, Locations, and Workouts, all of which sound like reasonable places to put your route file.
My riding buddy Davo Mac, a guy with one of the sunniest dispositions I know recently entertained a group of us confederacy of cruisers bike tours new orleans la a 5-minute rant about many of these Garmin ways of doing things from the breadcrumb map starting point down through the route file uploading.
Worse, they embarrassed themselves with their own segments offering which has never caught on. Like, right away. Here, the BOLT really excels. The completeness, organization, and presentation of the data are so much better on the BOLT than the I hardly feel the need to dig into my TrainingPeaks computer program more than once vike week. Here are a couple comparisons of the presentation of results elwmnt different rides including a couple to the far right with Zone details that are only available with the BOLT.
Click here to read about who we are, what we do, and why. Thank you for reading. Even though it is quite extensive, it is not quite detailed, as is customary in classic cyclocomputers or sporttesters.
Functions — not all functions are decomposed. Certainly these meters are packed with a lot of features.
The LAP function peaks, split times. There is no indication of how many times it can handle What data will show me. And if I know these figures self-select and paste. Language-do not know whether it has Czech or Slovak language. Even though I think yes, compatibility with Watt meters in cranks SRM, Garmin, Rotor, Powertap … is not written Also, it is not written whether it is possible to combine it with Watt meters in the chest belt, for elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin in other sports like cycling elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin running, cross-country, inline, swimming … 5.
Bracelets — I can not find out if bracelets are available for placing the meter on the wrist or on the shoulder. What I learned from the net: Navigation does not have street names when you get off the route — you can not get back.
Very large differences in altitude, temperature, and percentages of climbing and falling. Inaccurate info about the power zone. Being in zone 3 is not exactly accurate. Others refer to 3. Electronics companies, and certainly cycling electronics companies are certainly doing this.
Gps for nockamixon mountain bike trails, they are a elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin their products more intuitive and self-guided and b using support pages on their websites or chat services available to answer their questions.
Wahoo does a good job of both of these. Go to https: Functions — All the features nearly all road cycling enthusiasts would need are available in the Bolt 2. Not sure I understand your questions about self-select and paste. When I open my lap display, elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin shows dragon touch action camera vision 3 the laps by number in order of the laps starting from the first time I hit the lap button 3.
Wahoo support would certainly know. You English is quite good though. Perhaps a 3rd party provider makes one. Perhaps a market opportunity for someone? Navigation — Bolt shows the street name in the turn-by-turn directions. And yes, it will not navigate you back on course if you go off. It will tell you are off course. When this happens to me, I simply turn around and return to where I made the wrong turn.
They each put out slightly different numbers because they operate slightly differently. Hard to know if one or either is exactly right but neither is very far off the other on a percentage basis. And while zone 3 is accurate, knowing that you are at 3.
Hi, Steve. Your info elwmnt valuable to us.
I have answers from Wahoo. It has a maximum of 65 LAPS. No dakine rasta mountain biking gloves needed. A 32 start or sprint can be done. Functions can choose anyone they want from options. Other manufacturers do not offer it for LAPS. Accordingly, a hand strap can be attached to the stem holder.
Winter run and skiing. Performance-wise, it is capable of doing all the things that the Edge can do plus it offers enhanced analysis when you use a power meter with it. The very cheapest cycle computers will measure the basics such as your speed and cadence and from these calculate things like your averages speed and average cadencetaking these figures from speed and cadence sensors located on the bike frame, to which they are connected using wires.
This means that you can use them as GPS computers, tracking your ride to upload it to Strava elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin you get home. Just make sure your phone is fully charged when you leave the house. At this price point, manufacturers prioritise gqrmin of use, small size and low weight garmon usually well below g. The GPS unit will typically track your ride statistics such coputer distance, time, speed and lap times but will not provide navigation.
Ride data is typically displayed in two or three rows of monochrome text. There may commputer elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin option gamin specify which data items and how many rows are displayed, but one of the selling points of these devices is that you turn them on and start cycling without needing to delve into complex configuration options, so personalisation tends not to be a priority.
The GPS may also allow you to set alerts when you have reached a target value such as having ridden for a pre-specified time. You may get virtual competitor functions, so that you can see how well you nashbar single speed mountain bike doing compared to elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin rides of the same route. Spend a bit more and you will start to get additional functionality in your GPS. A mid-range unit will usually be larger with a larger screen which can display more data, often in colour.
Data storage capacity will probably elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin increase. The unit may be controlled by buttons or a touchscreen. Many mid-range units add mapping and navigation functionality. You can buy GPSs which major on this functionality, although others still where to buy shimano rw5 winter road cycling shoes support breadcrumb trails.
Because of the way in which GPS satellite triangulation works, altitude data calculated elemnt gps bike computer vs garmin GPS is less accurate than positional data. Thus higher spec GPSs will often add a barometric altimeter to increase recording accuracy for height and rate of ascent. Many mid-range units now include Bluetooth synchronisation to a smartphone. This allows alerts to be displayed on the GPS when an incoming call, text or e-mail is received. Other data from the phone, such as weather conditions, may also be displayed on the GPS.
Some cycle computers send data back to the phone, so it can transmit ride progress data to the internet, where people you allow can view it, and let you upload your rides without needing to connect to a computer. The arms race in high-end cycle computers continues and manufacturers seem to be announcing new top of the range features every few months.
News:Aug 9, - Focus on these questions to determine which model is best for you. The Garmin Edge is a feature-loaded bike GPS with many unique It's also a durable little bike computer with an intuitive interface and . The Wahoo Fitness Elemnt Bolt is one of the smallest and most aerodynamic bike GPS on.
Leave a Comment